A sultan has 9 pearls that look identical, but one is slightly heavier. It has a two-pan scale. You must identify the heaviest pearl by using the scale the MINIMUM number of times possible, because each use of the scale costs one gold coin. How many weighings do you need at least?
12th century Persian riddle
Home > Riddles > The wise men and the pearls (ancient Persia)
The wise men and the pearls (ancient Persia)
Hints
Show hints
- Think about information capacity: each weighing has 3 possible outcomes (heavier left, heavier right, balance).
- First weighing: divide the 9 beads into three groups of 3 and compare (A, B, C) vs (D, E, F), leaving (G, H, I) out.
- Second weighing: if the first balance is balanced, compare G vs H (if they tie, the weighing is I). If there is no balance, compare two of the heaviest trio to identify the pearl.
Solution
Show full solution
Answer: 2 heavy.
Explanation:
First weighing: Divide the 9 pearls into three groups of 3: $(A, B, C)$ vs $(D, E, F)$, leaving $(G, H, I)$ out.
If balanced:
The heavy pearl is in $(G, H, I)$.
- Second weighing: $G$ vs $H$
- If $G$ heavier $\to$ $G$ is false
- If $H$ heavier $\to$ $H$ is false
- If balanced $\to$ $I$ is false
If $(A, B, C)$ heavier:
The heavy pearl is at $(A, B, C)$.
- Second weighing: $A$ vs $B$
- If $A$ heavier $\to$ $A$ is false
- If $B$ heavier $\to$ $B$ is false
- If balanced $\to$ $C$ is false
Result: 2 weighings guarantee identifying the heaviest pearl.
Related riddles
Keep practicing
If you enjoyed this one, try more pure-logic riddles, explore this theme, browse the full archive, or read the riddle-solving guide.