Home > Riddles > The island of the ojos azules

The island of the ojos azules

Pure logicLevel 4/5

This issue does not add private information; adds something subtler and more powerful: common knowledge. That is why its solution seems slow and, at the same time, relentless.

On an island live perfectly logical people. Exactly 100 of them have blue eyes. The others have brown eyes, but no one knows the color of their own eyes.

Everyone can see everyone else's eye color. There are no mirrors or reflective surfaces. There is also a strict law: anyone who becomes certain of their own eye color must leave the island at dawn the next day.

One day a visitor arrives and says out loud: "I see at least one person with blue eyes."

What happens next?

Hints

Show hints
  1. Start with the smallest case: what would happen if there were only one blue-eyed person?
  2. Then try two blue-eyed people and compare what each one sees.
  3. Generalize from \(n-1\) to \(n\): if no one leaves before, what does that force on day \(n\)?
  4. From there, the argument chains by induction.

Solution

Show full solution

Answer: The 100 blue-eyed people leave the island at dawn on the 100th day. Explanation: The key is induction. - If there were 1 person with blue eyes, upon hearing “I see at least one” she would immediately know that person was herself and would leave the next day.

  • If there were 2, each one would see one. I would think: “If I weren't blue, the other one would be the only blue one and she would be gone tomorrow.” Since no one leaves on day 1, they both deduce on day 2 that they are also blue.
  • The same reasoning continues by induction. With 100 blue-eyed people, each one sees 99 and waits for 99 sunrises without anyone leaving. Since no one leaves in those 99 days, everyone simultaneously concludes that they also have blue eyes. That is why the 100 leave the island at dawn on the 100th day.

Related riddles

Keep practicing

If you enjoyed this one, try more pure-logic riddles, explore this theme, browse the full archive, or read the riddle-solving guide.

← Previous: The tower of Hanoi · Next: The three vessels of the wise man (India antigua) →